IJ recommends Joe Nation for state Senate seat
TWO QUALIFIED and experienced Democrats are fighting it out in a race that started more than a year ago. Sound familiar?
This campaign now involves three Democrats - and none of them are named Barack Obama or Hillary Clinton.
The race is for the Democratic nomination for the 3rd state Senate District, which includes Marin, southern Sonoma and parts of San Francisco. The candidates are incumbent Sen. Carole Migden, San Francisco Assemblyman Mark Leno and former Marin Assemblyman Joe Nation. Because Democrats dominate the district, the winner on June 3 likely will prevail in November.
The IJ recommends Nation.
All three candidates have impressive resumes.
- Migden, the first-term incumbent from San Francisco, is facing two challengers in large part because her personal behavior, including a bizarre freeway crash, and scores of campaign law violations resulting in a record state fine have made her vulnerable. If this race was just about her ability to deliver for her district, it would be no contest. She has been an effective legislator, and has been a constant presence in Marin since Leno entered the race, but she has betrayed the trust of voters. Her ethical violations and lapses of judgment cannot be rewarded.
- Leno, who is being termed out of his Assembly seat, announced more than a year ago that he was running against Migden. He also has spent much time in Marin and Sonoma of late. He is the chairman of the Assembly Appropriations Committee and also has been an effective state legislator.
- Nation, a climate change expert who represented the North Bay in the Assembly for six years before being termed out, entered the race a few months ago. He would not be running if Leno wasn’t in the race. Conventional wisdom says that Leno and Migden will divide the San Francisco vote, improving Nation’s chances because of his North Bay history.
Leno told the IJ editorial board that this race “is not about geography - it’s about effectiveness.” He says he is a better legislator than Nation.
Of course, this election is partially about geography. The 3rd Senate District is an odd creature that stretches from Hunters Point-Bayview along eastern San Francisco to Marin and southern Sonoma. A North Bay resident has not held this seat for more than 30 years.
Marin and Sonoma would benefit from a state senator who truly knows and understands local issues.
That would be Nation. The former San Rafael resident who also served on the Marin Municipal Water District board now lives in southern Sonoma.
This race is also about ideas and the state’s future. Nation, who was frustrated when he left the Assembly four years ago, is an economist and an expert on climate change - he teaches the subject at Stanford - who will play a leadership role in this increasingly important issue.
When asked about how to fix the state’s broken budget process, his rivals essentially blamed Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger for repealing the state vehicle license fee and Republicans for their vow not to raise taxes. Nation outlined a new “green” version of the license fee, one that would be based half on a vehicle’s value and half on its fuel efficiency. The fee would raise $6.1 billion a year. He would use half to provide incentives for people to buy more fuel efficient cars - rebates worth $1,500 to $2,000.
Nation also advocates slightly lowering the sales tax and broadening it to include services to increase state revenue and avoid the boom-and-bust cycles California has experienced of late.
He would continue to push climate change issues because he says we are running out of time. Nation says we have five to 10 years to get our act together before too much harm has been done. He helped shape climate reform efforts when serving in the Assembly and his expertise in this area is needed in the Senate.
Leno criticized Nation for saying he would never cut education, even with the state facing huge deficits and education accounting for half the state budget. Leno says such positions and votes would make Nation “irrelevant” as state senator and deny him any leadership positions.
There is some truth in that. Such absolute stances should be avoided when tough decisions are required. Marin’s senator needs to have a seat at the table when key decisions are being made - not be on the outside looking in.
But that senator also needs to bring fresh thinking and ideas to Sacramento.
All three are capable of doing the job. The IJ endorses Joe Nation because he would do the best job for Marin, for the district and for the state.